Sugar Review: A Stylish Neo-Noir Mystery

Rating: 7/10 ⭐️

Vinit Nair
2 min readMay 22, 2024

Apple TV’s new mystery series Sugar is a love letter to classic film noir, wrapped up in a stylish neo-noir package. The show follows private detective John Sugar (Colin Farrell) as he investigates the disappearance of a Hollywood mogul’s granddaughter. While the central mystery itself may not be groundbreaking, Sugar’s visual flair, atmospheric storytelling, and Farrell’s magnetic performance make it a captivating watch.

From the very first frame, Sugar immerses viewers in its neo-noir world through its striking cinematography and meticulous attention to detail. The show masterfully employs classic noir techniques, such as low-key lighting, deep shadows, and unconventional camera angles, to create a moody and enigmatic atmosphere that perfectly complements the unfolding mystery.

One of Sugar’s most distinctive and engaging elements is its frequent use of black-and-white footage from iconic noir films. These carefully curated clips, featuring stars like Humphrey Bogart and Gloria Grahame, are seamlessly woven into the narrative, serving as both a nostalgic nod to the genre’s roots and a clever way to illustrate John Sugar’s thought process and cinematic obsessions.

At the heart of Sugar is Colin Farrell’s mesmerizing performance. Farrell fully embodies the archetypal hard-boiled detective, complete with slicked-back hair, tailored suits, and a world-weary demeanour. His portrayal strikes the perfect balance between tough-guy swagger and vulnerability. Farrell’s smooth, sultry voiceovers add another layer of intimacy to the character, as we join him in his philosophical musings and wry observations.

Sugar is a treasure trove of references and homages to classic noir films, from its rain-soaked streets and flashing neon signs to its cast of morally ambiguous characters. By placing a film-obsessed detective at the centre of its story, Sugar invites us to appreciate the enduring appeal of noir and the way it continues to influence contemporary storytelling.

Sugar is a visually stunning and atmospheric neo-noir that succeeds in both honouring and subverting the conventions of its genre. Colin Farrell’s captivating performance, combined with the show’s impeccable style and self-aware storytelling, make it a must-watch for fans of classic Hollywood crime dramas and contemporary neo-noir alike. While the central mystery may not be groundbreaking, Sugar’s loving embrace of noir tropes and its exploration of the enduring appeal of the genre elevate it above its peers. With its intoxicating blend of style and substance, Sugar is a welcome addition to the neo-noir canon and another great show on Apple’s streaming platform.

--

--